For this month’s food review, I found myself in Deatsville eating at Sheila’s Pizza. I’ve eaten at Sheila’s before and I have always enjoyed myself there. It’s one of the best pizza places around in my opinion.
What I did for this review was buy a buffet lunch and decided to just try as many different pieces of pizza as I could, at least the ones they brought out to the buffet table.
The buffet is the best bang for your buck. For just $10.48, you get a drink, as much pizza as you can eat and a salad. I was asked what specific pizza I would like, so I chose the meats and just a plain pepperoni.
While I waited for mine, I found myself grabbing a slice of alfredo, chicken bacon ranch and buffalo chicken. So let’s talk about each one.
Alfredo: This was actually better than I expected. Whoever ordered it did not get chicken on it, which was disappointing, but it was good. Tasted great and it was not too overwhelming. I had one piece of spinach and it was great. I would eat it over and over again.
Chicken bacon ranch: This was the worst slice of pizza I found myself with during my lunch visit. Don’t get me wrong. If you’re into chicken bacon ranch, you’ll like it. But for me, it was extremely overpowering and it was just so different from the other slices I didn’t enjoy it at all.
What I did enjoy was the buffalo chicken. To me, this was the best piece of pizza I ate the entire trip. The buffalo was not too strong, but it was still the highlight of the slice. Buffalo can sometimes be overpowering (not the heat, just the taste) and it had a great amount of onions and the chicken was the perfect size.
My slices came out shortly after and the meat was better to me. A meat pizza is always my go-to, and I’ll probably just get it again when I go back. Crust was hard and firm, which was the best because all the meat stayed on the pizza and wasn’t just falling apart when you picked it up. And there was so much sausage that when you took a bite, sausage was literally coming off the pizza. It was fantastic.
The pepperoni, which is just a classic, was on the lower end for me. The crust was very soft and droopy, and the cheese was sliding off when you picked it up. It tasted exactly how you wanted it to taste, but I like my pizza a little more firm than what I picked up. Plus, there wasn’t much pepperoni on the pizza. I think my slice only had two pieces on it, which isn’t enough for just a plain pepperoni pizza.
All in all, I had a great trip. I’ve always had a wonderful time there, and the food is always great. Go check it out, because you’re not getting a better bargain.
